Heated back and forth between defence and prosecution
Earlier in the morning, the jurors also asked the court for copies of the testimony of three of the accusers, including Carolyn, Annie Farmer, and “Jane”, so they could review their accounts, in what could be seen as another positive sign for Ms Maxwell. The British socialite looked relaxed and happy at the morning’s developments, and at one point received a shoulder rub from her attorney Bobbi Sternheim.
However, the jury later came back with a third question on whether they could consider the testimony of Ms Farmer, who claims she was massaged naked by Ms Maxwell, in one of the six charges.
There was a heated back and forth between the defence and prosecution on what the judge should instruct them.
Maurene Comey, for the Government, told the judge: “A one-word answer would be correct here. They asked a very simple ‘yes’ ‘no’ question, the answer is ‘yes’.”
Christian Everdell for Ms Maxwell tried, unsuccessfully, to argue that the issue was more complicated. Ms Farmer was one of the prosecution’s most compelling witnesses, whose story has remained consistent over the years.
The jury broke for the day on Tuesday at 5pm after eight hours of deliberation. They will return on Wednesday at 9am local time.