Supreme Court to listen to non secular liberty dispute over highschool coach’s on-field prayers

NEWYou can now hearken to Fox News articles!

Joseph Kennedy likes to think about himself as a “big brother” of types to the numerous college students he has mentored through the years as a highschool soccer coach. 

“I remember the hundreds of times I told my players not quit no matter the challenge,” he advised Fox News this week.

But the previous Washington state resident is now in maybe the most important combat of his life, one which has taken him all the best way to the U.S. Supreme Court in a non secular liberty dispute over the bounds of exercising one’s religion in public.

The 9 justices will hear oral arguments Monday on whether or not the native faculty district correctly suspended Kennedy from his job at Bremerton High School, after he refused to cease praying on the sphere on the finish of video games.


A central query: Is a public faculty worker who says he’s praying by himself whereas at college and visual to college students partaking in “government speech” that lacks any First Amendment safety.

“The whole idea of just because I’m working there, I have no rights anymore as an American?” Kennedy mentioned. “When do I stop representing the school district? And that’s what we’re kind of asking, just a simple thing: Can I pray after a football game?”

The faculty district argues that the act was something however a non-public second of reflection, and that it regularly concerned public prayers with college students, a few of whom felt pressured to affix within the show.

“No child attending public school should have to pray to play school sports,” mentioned Americans United for Separation of Church and State president Rachel Laser, the group representing the college district. “No student should ever be made to feel excluded– whether it’s in the classroom or on the football field– because they don’t share the religious beliefs of their coaches, teachers or fellow students.” 

Former Bremerton High School assistant football coach Joe Kennedy at the center of the field on the 50-yard line at Bremerton Memorial Stadium.

Former Bremerton High School assistant soccer coach Joe Kennedy on the middle of the sphere on the 50-yard line at Bremerton Memorial Stadium.
(Larry Steagall/Kitsap Sun through AP, File)


Kennedy is an 18-year Marine veteran, who additionally labored on the native naval shipyard in Bremerton, about 20 miles west of Seattle throughout the Puget Sound. But highschool soccer is his ardour. Returning to his alma mater in 2008, Kennedy began as an assistant varsity coach.

“The prayer after the football game — that was just myself, I would just take a knee at the 50-yard line after football game,” Kennedy advised Fox News’ chief authorized correspondent Shannon Bream. “After a few months, the kids would say: Coach, what are you doing out there? And I just said I was thanking God for what you did. They asked if they could join. And I said: it’s America, a free country, you do what you want to do. And that’s how that kind of started.”

Kennedy praying on the field after the high school's homecoming game.

Kennedy praying on the sphere after the highschool’s homecoming recreation.
(Liberty Institute, File)


What started as a 15-30 second Christian blessing “quietly and alone” developed into one thing extra over time. Players and coaches from his and opposing groups would be a part of him in prayer on the sphere.

After about seven years, a number of mother and father started complaining, together with one whose son was an atheist and believed he wouldn’t get as a lot taking part in time if he failed to affix within the post-game prayer.

Another dad or mum, Paul Peterson, whose son performed on the staff in 2010, mentioned the sight of the coach on the sphere surrounded by kneeling teammates turned a “spectacle,” that put stress on different college students to observe.

In their authorized transient with the excessive courtroom, legal professionals for the college district argued, “Parents should not have to fear that the messages their children receive in Sunday school will be undermined by competing religious messages Monday morning in English class — or Friday night on the football field.”

But Jeremy Dys, an legal professional with First Liberty Institute, the group representing Kennedy, mentioned no coercion or instruction was concerned.

“Coach Kennedy simply wants to pray by himself at the 50-yard line. That’s the commitment he made before God,” Dys advised Fox News. “They [school leaders] refused to honor that. And now here we are seven years later, arguing about whether or not someone could be fired from their job just because the public can see him engage in a private act of worship.”



School officers say they repeatedly tried to accommodate Kennedy. After formal complaints in 2015, they despatched a letter requesting he cease praying with college students within the locker room and on the sphere. The faculty mentioned he might “engage in religious activity, including prayer, so long as it does not interfere with job responsibilities.”

Kennedy initially agreed, however after a month he partially reversed his stance and resumed his unique observe of on-field prayers instantly after video games.

The coach was then placed on paid go away. Both sides dispute whether or not he was later fired or determined ultimately to not return for the next season.

Lower courts have all dominated for the college. The ninth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals concluded that by kneeling and praying in view of scholars and fogeys, Kennedy “spoke as a public employee, not as a private citizen, and his speech therefore was constitutionally unprotected.”

The Supreme Court initially refused to become involved in 2019, as an alternative ordering a federal appeals courtroom to take a second take a look at the problems introduced. But 4 conservative justices warned on the time, that appeals courtroom’s “understanding of the free speech rights of public school teachers is troubling and may justify review in the future.” Joining Justice Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas on the time had been Justices Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh, two of President Trump’s appointees.

Fast-forward three years, and with a fortified 6-3 conservative majority, the excessive courtroom might now be poised to rule for Kennedy.

Joe Kennedy coached high school football in Bremerton, Washington.

Joe Kennedy coached highschool soccer in Bremerton, Washington.
(First Liberty)



It is a bedrock proper of the Constitution’s First Amendment:  “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.”

Tension between these authorities and particular person ideas has been particularly acute prior to now six a long time, as judges have been requested to ensure– when defending one facet, they don’t go too far in violating the opposite. The Supreme Court has interpreted such legal guidelines be enforced in a fashion that’s impartial towards faith, growing a balancing check when job-related speech could also be concerned.

The justices in different comparable previous disputes has typically prohibited public faculty prayer, even whether it is voluntary.

 In a 2001 ruling involving a Texas highschool coverage permitting student-led, student-initiated prayer at highschool soccer video games, the excessive courtroom discovered it violated the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment.

“On school property, at school-sponsored events, over the school’s public address system, by a speaker representing the student body, under the supervision of school faculty, and pursuant to a school policy that explicitly and implicitly encourages public prayer,” the courtroom majority mentioned that was not non-public, however reasonably public speech.

 “Regardless of the listener’s support for, or objection to, the message, an objective Santa Fe High School student will unquestionably perceive the inevitable pregame prayer as stamped with her school’s seal of approval.”

Three conservative justices dissented, together with Justice Clarence Thomas, who remains to be on the courtroom. They mentioned the bulk ruling “bristles with hostility to all things religious in public life.”

The Supreme Court in separate rulings has additionally blocked teacher-led prayers within the classroom and at commencement ceremonies, however allowed a pupil Bible group to satisfy on campus after class.

In a pending case argued final fall, the excessive courtroom will quickly determine the constitutionality of a Maine program that gives tuition help for college kids with no native public faculty to attend non-public establishments, so long as the funding just isn’t used for non secular or “sectarian” instruction.



The present dispute has triggered a high-stakes political divide.

Trump featured Kennedy at a marketing campaign occasion in Virginia in 2016 when working for president.

 “I think that is absolutely outrageous. I think it’s outrageous,” Trump mentioned on the time of Kennedy’s state of affairs. “I think it’s very, very sad.”

Supporting authorized briefs have been filed on this present attraction by former Vice President Mike Pence, and separate coalitions of former skilled soccer gamers, 24 conservative states, and GOP senators.

Groups on the opposite facet embody different retired NFL gamers, in addition to civil rights and nationwide non secular organizations.

When the Bremerton controversy was heating up in 2015, a couple of half-dozen pupil leaders and academics had invited the Satanic Temple of Seattle to attend a recreation in what they described as an expression of free speech, saying if Kennedy was allowed to wish publicly, so ought to they.

On the bigger constitutional questions, legal professionals for the college district say private religion is sullied when combined with authorities.

“Church-state separation means that no one should ever have to choose between their religious freedom and being part of the team,” mentioned Americans United chief Laser. “Our country is on perilous ground if the Supreme Court considers overturning decades of established law that prevents government employees from pressuring students to pray in public schools. That’s what makes this case so critical — a loss would dangerously erode a core principle of our democracy.”

As for Kennedy, he now lives in Florida, however promised to maneuver again to Bremerton if allowed to educate there once more. He says the prolonged courtroom fights are about greater than himself.


“The kids said: coach, can’t you just give in? And I realized if I did that, I would be going against everything I’ve ever taught these guys,” he mentioned. “You keep driving until the very end, until there’s nothing left on the clock. I would have been the biggest hypocrite in the United States if I would have just said: oh yeah, you’re right, this is too hard for me. What kind of example would I have set for my guys?”

The case is  Kennedy v. Bremerton School District (21-418). A ruling is predicted by late June.

Source hyperlink

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.